Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Module 2 Discussion Question

Raising a child with an autism spectrum disorder can be very stressful for families. Caregivers have to become interventionists for their child and advocates for their well being which can put a heavy burden on the family. Because of this, they may be defensive or argumentative at an IEP meeting as they are struggling to ensure their child receives the necessary services and supports. What would you do if a parent questions the types of interventions the child is receiving at school and wants to see evidence that these interventions are having a positive impact on the child's development?

46 comments:

Britton said...

To alleviate concerns of parents as to the effectiveness of strategies used with their child, a teacher can present data and explain the data. I like to share concrete information with the parent, such as, "Ron greeted me only 3 times upon entering my classroom last week, but he greeted me every day this week" or Ron read 78 wpm on a 9th grade passage in April, but is now reading 93 wpm on that passage. The proof is in the data!

Brewington said...

I agree. Keeping your data and keeping it up to date is the most important thing you can have to support what you are doing with a student in your classroom. Having the data there to show and discuss with your parent should alleviate the concerns of the parent.

Cathy Parker said...

I try to involve my parents as much as possible in the process of their child's education. Of course this differs from parent to parent depending on the actions of that parent. At a meeting it is easy and effective to provide the data showing the progress of the student. I can also pull a file of student work (depending on the goal) and have been known to snap a picture or make a video showing mastery of that goal. In addition, the related service providers' data usually coincides with my data collected on the student. I find that homework assignments help the family to see progress on the goals and objectives.

Cathy Parker said...

I agree with the other comments given that current data is a very effective tool in supporting the activities in the classroom. Even if porgress slows for a short time the dates on the data can help to pinpoint problems that the student may be experiencing during that period.

Anonymous said...

First off, I would do my best to prevent this situation from occurring. Keeping parents informed of their child’s progress, or lack there of, is extremely important. Providing progress reports throughout the year (data included) will inform parents of their child’s progress on goals/objectives. Adjustments can be made at in interim IEP meeting if changes on goals/objectives or even supplementary services/supports are warranted. If a parent does question the type of intervention(s) and its effectiveness, I would provide them with various forms of evidence. This could include and is not limited to data sheets, student work sample, notes from classroom observations, school behavior reports and attendance records. For example, our school psychologist runs a social skills group as a related service. This is the first year that this service has been provided at my school. We work collaboratively and I take the data in class to see if they are transferring the skills learned in group to the classroom environment. This data is shared at the IEP meeting to justify the need and progress of the group. I have worked with parents who are skeptical about pulling their child out to work on social skills. It is extremely important that I provide these concerned parents concrete evidence that this service is having a positive impact.

Anonymous said...

Absolutely! The proof is in the data! We are required to use SRA for our students at the middle school level. One of the things that I like best about the program is that provides you with sufficient data. The program provides frequent fluency/comprehension checks and mastery tests. I use this information for progress reports and IEP meetings. It is also helpful when other present level testing shows the same progress.

Melissa Melton said...

The right thing to do would be to explain in lay terms the research basis for the use of that particular intervention followed up with actual data from the implementation of that intervention with the individual child. Start by looking at the technical data including graphs which provide simple visual proof of positive trends and then fill in with objective statements from all of the team members as to how this has manifested itself in fucntional, real world situations whenever appropriate. Compare and contrast how often and how well the child is diplaying the behaviors at home versus school, etc. to help to determine how much is being generalized and to ensure that everyone remains consistent in their expectations and implementation to maximize success.

Melissa Melton said...

I agree with the other comments that the proof is in the data and that whenever possible, we as practitioners are responsible for making efforts to keep parents informed by giving evidence of their children's progress on a frequent enough basis that it should not be new information at an IEP meeting. Daily or weekly progress sheets are time consuming but are so valuable in making a parent feel that they are an important member of the team and that we want them to see and know what we see and know. It keeps things less formal and I feel more conducive to an open relationship.

Jordanadan said...

I work with students who are more cognitively challenged and all lack verbal abilities. This is really hard for some of my parents because their children cannot come home each day and let them know what they are doing in school. I use daily communication folders to let parents know what we are working on daily. I also give them frequent updates on how their child is performing on certain tasks. I also share photographs of activities and invite parents in to see how we do certain tasks. I feel that by doing this it alleviates some of the stress at IEP time because parents feel that they are an active part of their child's education. I also take time prior to meeting for the IEP to get parent input on skills that they view as important for their child's success and independence. I feel that this is very beneficial when addressing independent living skills and how it relates to each child's home life.

Anonymous said...

I never wait until a formal re-evaluation or an Annual Review to keep parents informed. I have a weekly sheet I send home where a parent can see what Tyler has done for the week. At the bottom I ask for parental feedback and I always called on the following Monday to make sure the parents concerns were addressed. I also had meetings every four weeks to help the parent, this may sound like alot but in the end the hostile parents I met three year prior were now easy to deal with and the meetings were so much easier.

Anonymous said...

Britton I agree with you when you say the proof is in the data. Data is so important. Keepins a parent out of the loop can be the worse thing for an IEP Team. Parents can be the best assessment for the chils

brewington said...

Hopefully this would not happen and in preventing it from happening... I use weekly progress reports, phone calls, and notes/email. This helps to keep the parents informed with what is going on with their child. When it is time for an IEP meeting, the parents are normally already aware of what is going on with their child.

SusanHGilstrap said...

Melanie Endres is right. By keeping parents informed daily (or as frequently as possible), parents will know that the teacher is trying very hard to meet the needs of their autistic child. If a teacher keeps the parents informed, there are no "surprises" at the IEP meeting, and the anxiety level and defensiveness decreases.

gardin said...

Absolutely keep good data! Try to collect data on every goal. The parent may be seeing something that we have overlooked in an attempt to help the child. I once had a parent question why their child was receiving oral accommodations for tests. They felt their child could read well enough on their own and the orals were holding them back. We had an interim IEP meeting, changed the IEP, and the child's grades actually improved. This is of course just an example and the child was not autistic, but I would definitely listen to what the parent's concerns were and use my data to support my viewpoint. Keep in contact with parents and let them know what is going on. They want to be a part of the education of their child and we make it harder on ourselves when we try to shut them out. When you work to keep parents in the loop, you are building yourself a support, not a battle. They know what to expect in the annual review because they know what has been going on all along.

bryant said...

I agree with everyone that data is key in working with any student. Not only keeping it, but analyzing it to effectively drive your instruction and to ensure that you are always following the child and remaining on the cusp of his/her learning needs.



I have always had an open-door policy with my parents, and they are always encouraged to come and observe their child during a lesson to not only keep them aware of their child's progress, but to also provide them with valuable tips to use at home, as well as give them an opportunity to share tips with me. This makes the parent feel more like a team member in the education process. I also provide daily comments on a communication log keeping parents up to date on progress, behavior, up-coming events,etc. The log provides a place for parent comments as well so that there is always an open line of communication.

Britton said...

And keeping parents updated is an entirely different issue with an 18 year old. We want to keep age appopriate activities always; so weekly reports are not something I would do for most of my high school students, except at parent request or special cases.

gardin said...

I agree with Britton that we need to make sure our activities are age appropriate. What worked for an ASD child in kindergarten may not be the same strategy I want to employ in 4th grade. I need to ensure that what I am doing is in the best interests of the child and not simply what "has always been done."

SusanHGilstrap said...

The autistic student I had this year began to show signs of having a lot of anxiety about school, and he began to act out more and more each day. I would meet with his mother everyday after school to discuss his day. I kept her completely in the loop (I felt) about every move we made with him. She was always very supportive of everything that we (the learning specialist and I) did for him. However, when we had his IEP meeting, the mother questioned every intervention that we were using. We were floored, especially since she was constantly updated and knew everything that went on each day.

So, we tried a different approach. We had the Autism consultant for our region to meet with us, and explain why each of the interventions were in place, and how it helped him. I think that once the mother heard it from an outside source, she was even more relieved.

Our school has a "behind the glass" classroom, and I used it one day. We allowed her to watch him for the better part of a school day (he didn't know she was watching). That really opened her eyes, as well.

Candace Morris Shockley said...

First, with any student, you should have good records and notes. If you are going to bring up anything in an IEP meeting, you need to have evidence to support it. I have had one parent who would question everything done with her child, and would sometimes get defensive. If I just said, well we tried this, or he didnt do this, it did not go so well with her. If I had the actual paperwork and evidence to back myself up, she generally did not become as defensive. While it may be more work in the classroom, it can save you from trouble later on.

Candace Morris Shockley said...

I agree with Melanies comment. You do need to keep parents aware of what is going on the entire year, especially if there are problems. IEP meetings can be scary, overwhelming, confusing, and may other things to parents. If they have been led to believe that their child was doing great all year, then bombarded with things that did not work, they may get defensive. Very good suggestion!

Melanie Tanczos said...

Throughout the year, we have two parent conferences in addition to the IEP progress reports that are sent home every six weeks or so. During this time is when I provide parents evidence of their child's progress on IEP goals and any other concerns I may have. I also send home classwork for parents to initial and return. In addition to monitoring progress and keeping data, this all provides documentation of the progress their child is making, which should alleviate any concerns the parents may have.

Melanie Tanczos said...

I agree that it is important to have research to back why certain interventions are being used. In addition, having the data for each intervention clearly shows which ones work and which ones don't. It can also show what outside events or unstructured activities cause certain behaviors. So although some strategies may be working, when something unexpected changes, this is easy to see and adjust accordingly.

A Eller said...

One of my professional goals this year was to establish positive communication with the parents of my students. Fortunately I had parents who were ultimately concerned about the educational needs of their child and I spoke with them on a daily basis, either through telephone, notes, or conferences. If a parent were to question the types of interventions their child was receiving, I would show them data collected in the classroom, their journal, and also a file of their personal work. I would invite the parents to come to observe their child in my classroom so that they could see firsthand the impact the intervention is having on their child.

A Eller said...

I agree with Britton. You have to consistently document everything to cover all your bases. Data collection is essential. Not only does it serve as a great tool for the parents to view, but you can also look back on it to monitor progress.

Chandra Wilkins said...

Through years of practice it is always important to take documented evidence of the effectiveness of the strategies that were used with the student. I have always asked the parents for their input as to what they want their child to work on. It is important to have close contact with the parents.

Chandra Wilkins said...

I agree with Bryant and everyone else that keeping data is key in avoiding difficult situations in IEP meetings. I too have an open door policy with parents. I encourage them to come at any time to visit their child's class, this seems to ease the anxiety that the parent has.

Kelly Hollingsworth said...

I, like Michelle, work with students who are nonverbal. Therefore, they are unable to communicate with their parents what they've done at school. Parents really appreciate the extra time and effort that you put in to provide them with information about their child's progress. Also, like Britton said, parents/families really appreciate being provided with concrete data. It's always great to keep parents informed!

Kelly Hollingsworth said...

In my opinion, the best way to avoid this problem is to be proactive and stress the importance of us being a team very early on. The earlier you start building a relationship with the parents/caregivers, the more success you will have in earning their trust. I try to be proactive by communicating with them early and consistently. I have an informal meeting at the beginning of school where I ask questions about the child, like his or her favorite foods, favorite places to visit etc. and try to get to know the child. Then I talk about any medical needs and health concerns that could possibly be an issue. I make sure to give the parents plenty of talk time to share their expertise. I then bring up important dates (annual review, progress reports) and discuss communication methods with the parents. I have my parents sign a communication log when we have meetings, and I briefly describe what we talked about in our meeting on the log. I also keep a private data log where I record every meeting, phone call, note from parents, etc. with the outcome of each interaction that I can use if need be. Also, I send home “homework” sheets each week where the student (with the parents’ help) circles activities that he or she participated in, in addition to the daily communication folder. I try and keep them involved with interventions, strategies, and classroom methods so that they can carry them over at home. However, if after all of this the parent still has some concerns, I would share all data sheets and communication sheets with the parent. I would listen to their concerns and try to create/amend a plan that would be suitable for the child and all members of the team. Again, I believe that early communication is key and data collection is a necessity. These two factors affect the parents greatly.

Becker said...

II agree that proof can be shown through data. Data can be in forms of percentages, charts and graphs. Data can also be represented and sometime more convincible through standard tests. Parent love to see an improvement in standardized test scores, since they are familiar with them. Going from 4th grade level to sixth grade in any area is something that most parents can understand. Grade level is one thing parents can concretely grasp.

When giving data, to parent, one needs to be familiar with the parent education level. If you give a parent with doctorate level elementary level data, then more then likely the parent is gong want more proof. If you give a parent who dropped on eleventh grade master level data, then they would not understand the data and demand something more.

Becker said...

If a parent questions the types of interventions the child is receiving at school and wants to see evidence that these interventions are having a positive impact on the child's development, I would give the parent concrete examples on how the inventions are positively effecting the child live.

Most importantly I will each the progress report to show how the inventions are affecting the child in school. I would list each intervention on the progress report and give an example how it effect the child in his or her school day. On each progress report I will see to that it includes the prior one, so that the parent can see the improvements. If the parents demand more prove, I will increase the period between progress reports to shorter time span.

Ram said...

I agree with Kelly and others, the way to avoid this problem by proactive planning, building relationship with parent/caregivers to avoid problems like defensive or argumentative at the IEP meetings. It is important to make parent as a partner of Interventions and in the IEP’S

Ram said...

I believe in making parent/ Caregiver as a partner in our intervention plan and IEP .
Parent/Caregivers are the first person to be very stressful in families with ASD student.
As a teacher we need to provide privilege for parent/caregiver as a partner in all activities and plans for ASD student. Inviting parent with meeting, communicating parents regarding plans, progress, interim plans in IEP to achieve student goals, sharing strategies with parents, information and suggestions from parents in critical issues like
Medical, tantrums, likes and dislikes etc. Appraising the proactive information, data, progress reports, and prior to the IEP meetings. This information about the student will give clear picture to parent. Parent will come with the suggestions which are more useful to his child and share with the team to implement intervention having positive impact on the child’s development.

Anonymous said...

I TOTALLY agree with Cathy Parker, Kelly Hollingsworth, and Ram in saying, "I believe in making parent/Caregiver as a partner in our intervention plan and IEP."

I also agree with Britton and others that evidence within data is a key component.

Taking photos of our students' triumphs is a great idea Cathy!

Including parents as part of our TEAM is crucial in effective education.

If a parent were to question the types of interventions their child is receiving at school and want to see evidence that these interventions are having a positive impact on their child's development, I would support the parent with my patience and understanding. The parents MUST feel/understand my willingness to accommodate their ASD child within my regular ed classroom in order for there to be a positive relationship between the adults, thus allowing the student to blossom academically as well as emotionally within my room. I would invite the parents to visit my classroom often as evidence that interventions are successful.

kthembree said...

I agree that keeping data is essential. IT will help you show taht you are doing what is best for the child.

I would try to prevent this problem from happening. I would send home weekly behavior reports or log, follow up with positive phone calls or notes. I would also listen to any concerns the parents have and try to establish a bond between us so that we can work together to meet their child's needs.

Joan Fazzino said...

I would first start with positive comments about the child's progress and show data and graphs that confirm this.I would also have other IEP team members disscuss their observations of the child's progress.I would send home weekly reports on progress and call the parent periodically to relay positive feedback. My classroom is always open to the parents to come in and observe their child's progress.I would invite the parent in a friendly way to come and see for themself how their child is doing.

Joan Fazzino said...

I agree with Michelle that students who are cognitively challenged and have limited verbal expression may be more difficult for parents to know what is actually happening in their child's educational setting. Daily communication folders, photographs,videos and written records from other service providers can be very useful to show progress. It is also effective to disscuss with the parent what they view as the most important areas of concern in school and at home.

Stephanie Davis said...

As a special education teacher for over 20 years, IEP conferences are the worst. Many parents feel that it is a time for confrontation. And let's face it, when they walk into the room many times we are aligned around the table in a manner which is confrontational.

To alleviate this feeling, I have an open door policy throughout the year. My parents are welcome and their input is invaluable. They are the first line of defense for their children (in most cases). I try to use them as a resource. We talk often and share news daily about the children. Email is wonderful for those who have it, the children also learn another form of communication.

Parents really just want to know what is going on at school, are there children safe, are they learning something meaningful, and will they be able to live independently and be a productive member of society? I know that sounds simple but in reality, parents of "normal" children want the same things. I treat my parents as if they are normal just like the rest of us. I explain things to them. I review the IEP and tell them what all those initials are for. I sit beside them at the IEP meeting. I engage them in actively stating what their goals and expectations are for their child. I find this helps with breaking down the barrier.

I keep detailed notes on my students. In my lesson plans, I keep a running ledger of daily activities. It could be I just write that we had a good day. Sometimes I write that a student used several profanity words. Other times I might note that a student came in dirty or was overly hungry. I keep this on hand at all times.

I detail conversations I have had with parents by phone. I note date and time as well as what the call was pertaining to.

We also have cameras in our classrooms so that documents behavior.

All of these tools help me talk with parents and help them make informed decisions regardng their child's education.

Stephanie Davis said...

I agree with Britton on data collection as a strong tool to alleviate concerns and delvelop strategies but sometimes seeing is beleiving. I am one of those people who like the cameras in my room.

Stephanie Davis said...

I also agree with Melanie about keeping parents informed. I do a weekly newsletter and daily communication log for my parents. They know what is going on in the classroom with no surprise punches.

Doris Bright said...

I would first listen to the concerns that the parent has. I have had meetings where concerns were justified due to a lack of communication and understanding of goals. Then present the data collected to show that when one approach was not working, another plan to reach the outcome was attempted. Most importantly would be to be sure the parent knows their opinion is important and that all avenues would be attempted. Through good data collection one can show modifications if one approach does not work. If data has been kept and all attempts and modifications/adjustments have been made the parent would most likely understand. Perhaps they would have an alternate approach??

Doris Bright said...

I agree with Melissa that explaining things in lay terms works best. I have been in meetings that language has been a big hinderance in progress. Parents have looked totally lost, with all of the other members discussing the student. This causes so much undo stress for the parent. Also, I think we all agree, proof is in good data collection.

Tracy said...

In order to be prepared for parents with questions regarding interventions being used and the impact of those interventions, I encourage teachers to keep data sheets and logs of interventions. The data sheets and/or logs should include the frequency, duration and/or intensity of the intervention as well as the results. Having data to support what is said or written into an IEP is helpful. The teachers I work with also have to keep portfolios with documentation to support mastery or nonmastery of each IEP goal/objective. The portfolio also contains data from the previous school year. Having this portfolio and data from the current and past teachers, helps guide the IEP team and parents.

A Eller said...

One way I get my students to communicate is through play. I teach 5-8 year olds so I am constantly on the floor and running around to keep up with them. During center time, I go in each area (housekeeping, art, writing, blocks, etc) and "play" with the students. The whole time I am engaging in conversation with them. In order to get students to communicate with you, you have to get down on their level. By doing this, they will know you are interested in what they are doing and they will initiate conversation through play.

Shelley said...

All teachers should be collecting and evaluating data on all students regardless of their ability. This gives them the chance to look at if what they are doing is making a difference and allows them to know when and if change is needed in making sure students needs are met. If a parent questions on if what the teacher is doing is successful, then the teacher should have data to support what they are doing and to provide that information to the parent. Teachers often do not feel as if they are completley prepared to teach students with ASD, so if they are questionable about methods and interventions, they should contact their district special services department and see if their district has an autism or ABA specialist or if they havef someone who is educated in working with kids with ASD and have them come in and teach them methods and interventions for working with these students as well as possible ways to keep data on students progress.

Shelley said...

I totally agree with Britton... The proof is in the data! You can't state if something is successful or not if you don't have data! As adults, isn't that what we want too? We wouldn't go to our stock broker and ask which one was doing pretty good or making improvements and just go on that information, we would want to see data that shows what change that stock is making and how long it has been making it. Just as we want to see proof of change, parents do as well.

Shelley said...

Melanie is right on it with keeping parents informed. We can prevent a lot of upset parents by just keeping them involved and informed. Parents most often are upset when they don't feel in the loop and don't feel as if they have any input in the choices that are being made on their child's education.