Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Module 1 Discussion Question

Choose one characteristic of students with autism spectrum disorders that you feel should be carefully considered and addressed when developing an intervention program within a general education classroom. Explain why you chose that characteristic as the most critical issue to address.

46 comments:

Cathy Parker said...

Within a general education classroom are students with varying needs. Learning styles differ greatly. I feel that the teacher must be acutely in tune with the sensory issues possessed by the ASD student. Naturally the teacher would address the visual, auditory and kinesthetic learning styles to ensure that all students in the class are best served. This may be detrimental to the ASD student with over-sensitivity to the activities as presented by the instructor. It is often a fine line between interesting, attending,and over stimulating. This is a critical issue since the ASD student can not process the material being taught if they are trying to avoid the offending stimuli. This may often lead to undesired behavior. Other issues may be easier addressed as motor skills, medical problems, and social proximity. Communication can be flexible with the use of eye gaze, verbalizations, sign language, PECS, or communication devices. Sensory issues are extremely important to address in the class with an ASD student to be successful.

Britton said...

I agree with your comment, and I think flexibility on the part of the general education teacher is critical. The student with ASD must be allowed to sit where comfortable in the classroom and perhaps engage in behaviors to calm self when overstimulated, such as doodling or stepping to the back of the classroom briefly.

Britton said...

A critical characteristic that I feel must be discussed with those in the general education setting is the characteristic of anxiety, and, if present, the resulting tantrums of the student when anxious or upset. Without an understanding of those characteristics, a general education teacher may inadvertently increase the anxiety level of the student. Without an understanding of the tantrums as having a distinct cause, such as a change in routines, a teacher may be alarmed and even afraid of a student with ASD.

Candace Morris Shockley said...

I agree with a need to address sensory issues. This is such a broad category that it really takes a lot think about. First you have to really be in tune with that student, and in a general ed class with 30 other students, this can be hard. Then you really have to think about everything that can lead to sensory issues, sounds, other students, work assignments, classroom decorations, temperature, and the list can go on and on. I agree with your comment on not being able to process information when over or under stimulated. It would make it extremely difficult.

Candace Morris Shockley said...

I believe that communication issues should be carefully considred and addressed when working with an autistic student in the general ed setting. I feel this is most important because to really work well with any student, you need to try to get to know them and as much about them as you can. While you can use many tactics to find these things out, verbal communication plays a large role in this, which many of the students with autism may have difficulty with. It also can lead to problems with other students in the classroom. I feel communication is the key in the classroom, and if there is a break in this, then it may only increase the behavoir issues, senosry issues, anxiety issues and much more with the student.

Ram said...

I agree with the comments of both. characteristics of Sensory issues and Anxiety are important in the general education classroom.
Impairment of social interaction is stepping stone for all challenges for the ASD student in general education classroom. Autistic chldren are not only very different from other peers, but often fail to inter act with other. High inter-individual and intra-individual heterogeneity of autistic children's social functioning and social understanding is a key linking their communication problems with circumscribed congnitive deficits.

Ram said...

I feel Critical characteristic of students with Autism Spectrum Disorder must be considered and addressed when developing an intervention with in the general education classroom is impairment of social interaction. Primarily general education classroom teacher should know about the Impairment of social interaction of the ASD student. Generally the teacher would address the visual, auditory and kinesthetic learning styles to ensure that all students in the class are best served. But with the students with ASD having difficulty with Social interaction.
Due to impairment in the use of nonverbal behaviors such as eye contact, facial expressions, body posture, an social gestures it is difficult to general education teacher whether the ASD student understand and comprehend the concept or not. ASD student will have a characteristic of being in their own world and student has a difficulty establishing developmentally appropriate peer relationships, so he unable to exchange his/ her view to other peer with the content or other needs. Impairment of social interaction will make failure to spontaneously seek opportunities to interact with other people (Interact in classroom when the instruction is taking place and clarifying doubts with the other peers). Student with ASD has poor social or emotional reciprocity. Without understanding of those characteristics, a general education teacher may be upset with that student’s response in the classroom and there is danger of ignoring him in class. When developing the intervention program within general education classroom , Teacher need to plan to attend the ASD student with personnel attention and interact more number of times. Some students will be more responsive to antecedent prompting than others. Selecting social interaction procedures based on individual subject, setting, and other salient variables increases the likelihood of successful outcomes. In consultation with the special education teacher, general education teacher can plan to implement the interventions which are appropriate to the ASD student. Social interaction is panacea for ASD student's success in the general education classroom.

Anonymous said...

I found it extremely difficult to pick one characteristic to focus on. As an inclusion teacher, I have worked with several ASD students. When developing an individualized intervention program, I have to carefully look over each child's individual impairments. The focus is then placed on the area that I feel will hinder their success the most in the classroom. It is also important to assess the general education teacher's personal knowledge and experience with ASD students as well. However, I do believe the most critical issue to address is Impairments in Social Interaction. I found this to be the most common characteristic shared among most ASD students. Social impairments can have a negative spiraling effect on a student who is in an inclusive environment. Poor peer/teacher interactions may lead to an increase in all of the other deficit areas (communication, anxiety, tantrums, attention). When in a general education setting, it is critical that a plan be created that will help the student be socially accepted. As Ram said in his response, the general education teacher (as well as the students in the class) needs to have an awareness and understanding of these characteristics. The classroom teacher may need to create opportunities for peer interaction so that age-appropriate social skills can be practiced/observed. When impairments in social interaction are addressed, students with ASD are more likely to feel like they "fit in".

Anonymous said...

Candace, I agree that that communication issues need to be addressed. I worked with an autistic middle school child who had extremely delayed language. He would often get frustrated and throw tantrums because he couldn’t get his message out. Often times, he would shake violently in his desk. For those who did not know him, they were afraid that he would get violent and hurt someone. But, those who knew how to communicate with him knew very well that his was not going to hurt anyone. Once communication strategies were implemented (by teachers and students), he found success in other areas!!

Jordanadan said...

In the general education environment I think it is also vital to educate the other children of the needs of the student with ASD. In doing this the hope is to create a community environment that embraces differences and can be used to the advantage of the teacher in addressing the communication and social issues related to ASD. In a learning community the teacher can create situations to address social and communication needs. With this type of buy in, the child with ASD not only has the support of the teacher but also the support of peers. Occupational therapists are a great resource for finding tasks or small "fidgets" that may reduce anxiety and can also serve as calming agents to reduce anxiety and in turn tantrums that arise from over-stimulation.

Melissa Melton said...

It is so hard for me to choose one aspect to consider because all aspects are important to gaining a unique, holistic picture of an individual with ASD. However, I would want to focus first on the sensory issues that many students face because I think it can be very difficult to believe how negatively a person can be affected by stimuli that seem to most of us to be minor, such as:
- the type and brightness of lights
-whether the lights give off sound
-whether there are windows and what can be seen from the windows
-the type of clothing that the child is wearing and whether it is comfortable for them
-the arrangement of centers, bulletins, materials, etc. in the classroom with attention to details as minute as the amount of color, the shapes, the characters, etc.
I think it may be difficult for people who are unfamiliar with austism (as it was for me) to understand the impact of such seemingly inconsequential matters, but by carefully addressing this issue and listening to and learning from the people who know the child best (parents, therapists, etc.) these triggers can be pinpointed and dealt with before they lead to tantrums, distractibility, and the resulting reduction in the effectiveness of instructional delivery.

Melissa Melton said...

I agree with Michelle that an important part of creating success in the general education environment includes educating the other children of the needs of the student with ASD. For many children, their first encounter with an indiviudal with ASD is in the public school setting, and there may be fear and anxiety on the part of these non-disabled students if they are not given an idea of what to expect, what to ignore, and when and how to interact. If other students are prepared to accept and welcome the individual with ASD, there is likely to be less anxiety on the part of everyone and this can lay a foundation for a true classroom community.

SusanHGilstrap said...

I think that Cathy Parker "hit the nail on the head." Learning styles are so tremendously different among autistic students, and it is the teacher's job to find out what works best for each of his/her students.

I had an autistic student in my third grade class this year, and he had been with the same group of children since kindergarten. The children were all very loving and super-sweet to him, but by third grade, he had hit the workload that was harder for him. His anxiety level increased almost daily. After about the first 9 weeks of school, he would have tantrums (and go under his desk and cry) when he became frustrated with his work. It broke my heart!!

Our school's learning specialist contacted the Autism director in our area---Faye Blaser---and she provided several tips that helped make his year so much more smooth. The help she provided me (in teaching me how to find his learning style, and my teaching style) was such a success!

Anonymous said...

Obsessive-repetitive behavior is a core feature of autism. The student I had constantly rearranged objects and this interfered with his participation in classroom activities. This behavior was successfully reduced by providing structured opportunities to select and use preferred leisure activities. Provision of structured leisure opportunities could be conceptualized as an antecedent intervention that includes differential reinforcement of incompatible behavior. Although the treatment was generally successful, follow-up data indicated that long-term maintenance could be lacking. This treatment can be recommended given that it appears to be efficacious for applied settings, relatively benign, and easy to implement.

Anonymous said...

Melissa I agree with you when it comes to educating the other chidren in the classroom. I had a student with ASD for three years. By the end of his 8th grade years the students understood him more and even helped him therefore decreasing his anxiety levels. Next year he is looking forward to his high school year as a Freshman.

brewington said...

I have to say that I agree with all of the comments: learning styles, anxiety and tanturms onsets, communication,and socialization.

For me at this point in my career, I have not taught an ASD student. I feel the most important part for a general education classroom will be educated on the ASD student's needs. Once my students and myself were aware of the needs I feel communication, behavior, learning, and socaialization would come along.

Stephanie Davis said...

I agree with all of your comments and would like to add that not only are the characteristics of an ASD child an issue but so is the physical environment of the classroom. Many of the general ed classrooms do not have a place of comfort for our students. The rooms are utilitarian or over stimulated. There is generally not a happy medium in their design. There is usually not a "time out" place so to speak so the student needs to be removed from the physical setting all together if overly stimulated. Many times this is thought of as bad behavior by the general ed students when in fact it is nothing more than anxiety on the part of the ASD student.

Stephanie Davis said...

I beleive that all of the characteristics of the ASD child should be considered when placing that child within the regular education environment however, communication would be the one that stands out as being most important. While society is slowly changing to written word as the major form of communication, social cues and verbal usage are just as important. For the ASD child, these areas are often difficult. In our class at school, we have verbal and non-verbal children. We use pictures, colors, letters, signing, hand gestures, words, etc. You know name it, we use it. In the regular ed classroom, the teacher may not have the time to use all the methods necessary for communication with the ASD child. This can cause frustration for both the child and the teacher along with the other students in the classroom. A couple of methods we have utilized within in the regular ed classroom are the Buddy System and Shadowing. These methods provide the ASD student with support and allows the teacher freedom to address communication avenues with all her students.

SusanHGilstrap said...

The characteristic I feel that needs to be carefully considered is that of anxiety. Think about it: Even for those of us who are not autistic, when we are anxious about something, it is extremely hard to focus on anything except what is making us anxious. With an autistic student, this anxiety is magnified dramatically, making the ability to focus on classwork impossible.

When developing an intervention plan, I think that it is very important to know what works well for each autistic child, and have a plan in place to help the child cope with his/her anxiety.

gardin said...

I believe that communication can definitely provide a challenge in the classroom. I had a child with ASD who was language delayed. This child attended speech therapy for this reason. For the first 2 months of school, she would just not talk to me. Once we developed a relationship of sorts, she did begin to speak to me, but only if she initiated the conversation. If I initiated the conversation, she thought she was "in trouble" and would withdraw.
Other students around her had a hard time getting used to her need to rearrange their belongings. Everything on the table had to be in a certain location before she could finish any task and she spent a lot of time making sure the area was the way she needed it to be. Fortunately, she sat with a group of students who were able to grasp this quickly and they let her do what she needed.
I really feel that her acceptance in our class helped her achieve the level of success that she was able to achieve. I truly believe in that classroom community you are referring to!

gardin said...

In response to something Stephanie said about "time out" locations:

When my daughter was in first grade, she shared her class with a little boy with autism. He was very prone to outbursts due to frustration and anxiety. These outbursts would lead to hitting and biting if they progressed too far. Their first grade teacher had the idea of giving him a "safe place" to go when he felt that frustration building up. She hung a piece of cloth around a rectangular table in front of her desk. She pulled the opening back much like you tie up curtains. She filled this space with a crate of his favorite books (Dinosaurs) and a body pillow. He called it his "cave" and he would go there - on his own - when he needed to calm down. His words. When he had himself under control, he would rejoin the class. This helped control his outbursts so much. I am glad that his cave allowed him to remain in a general ed classroom. He is still in class with my daughter - going into 8th grade!

bryant said...

When considering the needs of the ASD child that I am working with now, sensory issues are very important. In that regard, I would have to agree with Cathy Parker. If sensory needs are not addressed, the entire lesson can be lost, and there is a fine line between interesting and offending. For example, if my student isn't provided with a warning(through use of a visual schedule) of a fire drill, the loud noise will send her to her "safe place" for quite some time, and consequently, the lesson will have to be postponed to a time when she is more receptive.



With that said, I also feel that addressing communication needs are just as important. The student that I work with has a very limited use of verbal skills and an even more limited ability to understand abstract concepts. Therefore, before we could even begin lessons, we had to create and implement a visual schedule to communicate with her. If she wasn't able to predict what was coming next in her day, or how long before she could go home, efforts to conduct a lesson were all but lost. She also learned how to indicate that she needed help or she needed a break. This helped to reduce frustration levels and helped us to work within her sensory needs, so to speak.

Melanie Tanczos said...

I also agree with Melanie that social interaction is important to focus on with students with ASD. My experience with middle schoolers with ASD showed me how important it becomes as students get older. Although these students have spent most of their school career together, by middle school, when hormones and social cliques are developing and changing, the once "cute" behaviors are not as accepted by peers any longer. If students with ASD are taught early on how to socially interact, when they reach middle school, and eventually the "real world" they'll have a greater chance to be successful.

Melanie Tanczos said...

As a general education teacher, it is very important to get to know each student with ASD individually, and create an intervention plan according to his or her specific needs. Although social interaction is important for students in the general education to understand, I feel another critical characteristic is communication. The general education teacher should develop lessons that allow the student with ASD to be successful. When students are given opportunities to use various modes of communication (written, verbal, computer, peer, etc.), the student may become more willing to participate in activities. If the teacher is not flexible in planning and is not willing to modify instruction, the student may become frutstrated with the type of assignment. This could lead to anxiety, stress, tantrums, etc. When a student with ASD is given more opportunities to be successful in class, and is not having as many tantrums or outbursts, then he is more likely to be accepted by his peers, which can help with social interaction.

Jordanadan said...

I agree with Melanie about students with ASD need to receive social skills instruction early on. I realize that when these students are young some behaviors can be viewed as "cute" but they do wear off as they become older and their peers are at a different stage developmentally. It is also important to collaborate with parents and to get a buy in from them for socially acceptable behaviors. Sometimes parents are willing to allow behaviors but if school and home work together it makes for a smoother transition especially when behavioral expectations are the same across the board.

Cathy Parker said...

I would agree with Stephanie Davis in the comment about space in the classroom. As we lose more teachers and classes are consolidated which means larger numbers of students in each class the classroom size does not change. With the traditional pressures and expectations placed on regular ed. students these new circumstances add merely exacerbate these situations. Not only does the ASD student need a "safe zone" (I would rather not call it a 'time out')but periodically so do some of the typical peers in the class. Yet, the teacher is expected to carry on and "finish that page each day" in preparation for the testing in the spring. It is hard to create that space and some teachers do not allow the reg. ed. pupils to engage in such a down time period. Everyone deserves that balance and also it helps to keep down resentment and bolster understanding.

Not wishing to offend anyone in this class but I would like to take a moment and mention Gena Linder Parker. She was an excellent teacher and widely respected in several counties by students, colleagues, and administrators. She kept her class entertained so that so many periods were not as needed. She had a genuine love for everyone and daily went two extra miles to ensure not only that the job was done but was done to the best of any one's ability. While visiting her mother in Cherokee County they were both tragically killed. Both of her parents were great educators, as well. All students have lost a great teacher and all teachers have lost a great friend. Thank you for allowing me to tell of this wonderful example of our profession.

Kelly Hollingsworth said...

Melanie E, I really like what you said about determining which area is going to hinder the student's success the most in the classroom and focusing on that issue. Based upon my experience, I would also agree that social interaction is definitely one of the most critical issues, especially for middle and high school students. These years are so crucial for these students academically. However, in most cases, academic success cannot be accomplished without adequate social interactions with both teachers and peers. Therefore, social interaction has to be addressed very early in the student's acadmic career in order for the student to be successful.

A Eller said...

One characteristic of students with autism that I feel should be carefully considered and addressed is communication. With their limited receptive vocabulary, it is very difficult for them to communicate their wants and needs. Often autistic children who have very little communication skills become easily frustrated and will resort to violent behaviors such as kicking, slapping, hitting, and sometimes growling in order to communicate their frustrations. This definitely impacts the area of socialization because other children will not be able to communicate with children if they engage in these types of behaviors, nor will they probably want to. The classroom teacher will have to implement other ways for the student to communicate his/her wants or needs in the classroom in a positive way.

Kelly Hollingsworth said...

While I strongly believe that all of these characteristics are critical, especially social interaction, I believe that communication can be the biggest barrier and should be the first priority of any intervention program. Most of my experience with ASD is with students who have more severe cases. In those experiences, tantrums and other behavior issues such as hitting, spitting, self-stim, etc... can be remedied when communication needs are met. When students don't have the ability/means to get across their wants and needs they become extremely frustrated. Therefore, they often act out (tantrums) or withdraw, which results in poor social interactions with peers and teachers. When they are given a means to communicate and can make their needs and wants known, they will be able to gain both academic and social skills. They will be able to communicate any sensory needs that are not being met as well as any medical needs that may be present. In my opinion, once a program has been designed to target communication needs, all other critical issues will be able to be resolved.

A Eller said...

I agree with what Melissa Melton said about sensory issues. If one thing is out of place or uncomfortable for the autistic child like fluoroscent lights or the type of clothing worn, it can make that child and the teacher's whole day shot. The child will react to this, most often in the form of a tantrum, and the teacher wastes very important instructional time having to calm and reassure the child.

Chandra Wilkins said...

All characteristics are important, however, I feel that communication is important when working with children with ASD. Within the general education classroom students would be able to communicate their needs whether orally, by signing, or with the use of technology.

Chandra Wilkins said...

I agree with Melanie in that communication issues need to be addressed as early as possible. Students with ASD need to learn to deal with anxiety, sensory issues, and other issues and communicate their needs. Students with ASD need to receive social skills instruction early on. Some behaviors are viewed as "cute" but the cuteness wears off as they become older and their peers are at a different stage developmentally.

Becker said...

The one characteristic of students with autism spectrum disorders that I feel should be carefully considered and addressed when developing an intervention program within a general education classroom is communication or lack of communication skills. There are some who cannot effectively communicate orally. These students my nod or point to what they want. The may use a communication board and other communication device. Some student s with autism spectrum disorder may experience extreme anxiety, when force to speak. This could be a catalyst to a tantrum. Once strategies have been develop to help this student, and then these should be made available to anybody that comes into the classroom to substitute for any period of time.

I think that this most important based upon what happen to one of ASD student. A substitute teacher cornered my ASD student in a corner and tries to force him to speak. The rest of students told the substitute that if he did not leave the ASD student alone, that the student will hit him. The substitute did not leave this student alone; The ASD student experienced extreme anxiety, his pickup an umbrella, and then hit the substitute over the head until it broke.

The ASD student was put up for expulsion and had manifestation meeting. It was decided in the meeting that the regular Ed teacher left no instructions on the strategies for dealing with the ASD student. It was found that the act was a manifestation of the disability and not to recommend expulsion. The substitute never was hire to sub or teach in county. The mother pulled the ASD out of school and home schooled him. This action made his social/ emotional deficits and communication skills become worse, to the point that he will never have the skills move out of his mother house.

Kimberly said...

I agree with the comment concerning flexibility. The general Ed teacher must learn to use the term fairness concerning an ASD child. Fairness means providing whatever each individual child needs to succeed. This may mean that an ASD child stands up during a lesson or sit in bean bag chair. It could also mean a child with ASD wears a set of head phones in class, because he sensitive to loud sounds. It could also mean the child with ASD only completes two of the ten problems assign.

General Ed teacher must look at each student with special needs as an individual. They must use whatever accommodations in the classroom that will allow the student to learn the material and be

Kimberly Becker said...

agree with the comment concerning flexibility. The general Ed teacher must learn to use the term fairness concerning an ASD child. Fairness means providing whatever each individual child needs to succeed. This may mean that an ASD child stands up during a lesson or sit in bean bag chair. It could also mean a child with ASD wears a set of head phones in class, because he sensitive to loud sounds. It could also mean the child with ASD only completes two of the ten problems assign.

General Ed teacher must look at each student with special needs as an individual. They must use whatever accommodations in the classroom that will allow the student to learn the material and be sucessful.

Anonymous said...

I agree with Becker and Hollingsworth that communication is the key for students with ASD to be successful in our general ed classrooms. It is imperative that the students feel a sense of belonging within their surroundings and being able to communicate is at the base of the entire experience.

Joan Fazzino said...

I feel the most important aspect in the general education classroom for a student with ASD is the social/emotional area. The teacher and reg.ed. students must have an understanding of how changes in activities or new events can cause anxiety for an ASD student. Prior notice of changes can help. Peers can often be "buddies" to the ASD child to promote smooth transitions.Peers can also encourage social interaction by initiating activities with the ASD child.

kthembree said...

I agree with Cathy Parker and feel that flexibility is one of the most important traits that an educator can have. You need to work with the child and find what that particular child needs and do your best to meet those needs.

I feel that another imporant aspect to work on with autistic children is communcation. You need to find some type of communication system that works best for that child. It is important that they have a way to communicate with you so that you can do your best to meet their needs. It may be a written communication, or it may be using pictures. Whatever is best for the child you are working with.

Joan Fazzino said...

I agree with Cathy Parker that sensory issues posed by the ASD student are very important to deal with in the general ed. setting. Students who are anxious or preoccupied with environmental stimuli cannot focus on lessons or retain information effectively.

Stephanie Davis said...

Gardin, you gave me a great idea for our autistic teacher. We have very limited funds as most of you do and creating a "cave" is a great idea. I hope it is OK to use. Thank you!

Doris Bright said...

There are so many issues in dealing with ASD students that it is very hard to pick one characteristic that is most critical. In being an SLP, I would choose communication. I feel that if the student cannot communicate, a spiral occurs with the behaviors (tantrums,repetition of actions and shut down). This also leads to other students fear of the student. Perhaps if the student could communicate he would say, "stop the noise" or "the light is too much" or "help". So to me some sort of communciation is critical, regardless of the approach chosen by those involved.

Doris Bright said...

I agree with Michelle in that others in the classroom and school setting need to be educated about the needs and individual "special" characteristics of these students. I have not worked with but a few ASD students, but am amazed at how the total school population in unaware of these special students. I have seen other "professionals" shy away or be unable to understand the needs.

Tracy said...

As someone in a leadership position, I agreed with most of the responses as I thought of the K-12 students in my school district. However, I have found that communication deficits is an area that needs to be carefully considered and addressed when developing an intervention program within a general education classroom. All students need the ability to effective use language. The lack of expressive and/or receptive language skills affects the ASD student's ability to establish and maintain relationships which in turn affects all aspects of social skills, leads to anxiety and even sensory issues. I believe that if ASD students had more opportunities for communication (even with assistive technology) their peers would change their attitudes and behaviors in regards to ASD students.

Shelley said...

Regardless of setting, I feel as if the most important characteristic of students with autism spectrum disorders that should be carefully considered and addressed when developing an intervention program. I feel this is the most critical of all characteristics to address because without the ability to communicate appropriately and effectively, students can become easily frustrated causing anxiety, frustration, and often behavior problems. It is essential that the intervention program address a child's communication needs while working on enhancing and building on their strengths to best enable them to be as functional as possible in any classroom setting, but especially the general education setting.

Shelley said...

I completley agree with Candace about addressing communication needs. Communication is key in the general education classroom for communicating with the teacher as well as with the other students.

Shelley said...

I like that Michelle feels that an important aspect of working with these students is to educate other students in the classroom and think that on some level this can be very true. However, as someone who works with many parents of autistic children, this is something that must be handled extremely carefully and must be at the consent of the parent. Although I do agree that this can be a great tool and can help these students be successful, we must also realize that it is up to their parents and them (if they are older) as to if they want other people to know of their disability and we must respect their privacy and their legal rights to that privacy if they choose for this information to not be made public.