Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Module 6 Discussion Question

If a student with ASD is having difficulty with reading comprehension even though the student is able to read the material fluently, what strategies would you use to increase the student's ability to summarize or re-tell the information that was read?

36 comments:

Anonymous said...

In order to improve a student’s ability to summarize, it is extremely important that they become actively engaged in the reading. This is certainly not an easy task for many students. A strategy that I have used encourages students to react to what they are reading. I have my students use small post-its with codes written on them (T-S, T-T, T-W, NC, ?, *) When they make a connection with something they have read, are unsure of a word, or have a question, they place the post-it on that sentence. When we are finished reading, we share our connections as a whole group or I have them share with their neighbor. I have even extended this to a writing activity where they complete a four square chart. The chart has an area for the chapter title, new characters/setting, predictions and connections. The last square is used to write a short summary. To differentiate, pictures can be drawn in place of a written response. I find that this activity promotes engagement with the text and helps students to summarize what they have read. I should also mention that this strategy was modeled many times by me as well as my stronger students. The conversations and connections the students have with each other are much like Reciprocal Teaching. It’s almost like a strategy within a strategy.

Joan Fazzino said...

Most of my students have very limited verbal expression. In order for them to retell a story visual aids are necessary. We use pictures, puppets, flannel boards and other props. The students enjoy taking turns telling the story with modeling from teacher and peers. Acting out the story is another way we have fun summarizing the main ideas. One of the best ways I have found to hold the attention of students with ASD is to write the words of the simple story on large chart paper and have a corresponding picture next to each sentence. After I read the story once the class helps me read it again by filling in repeated phrases or predictable words. They can identify different parts of the story from the visual cues. I also have them draw their own pictures and then type a sentence on the computer about the story.Some students will dictate a sentence to me and then copy it on the computer.

Melanie Tanczos said...

If a student with ASD is having difficulty with reading comprehension even though the student is able to read the material fluently, what strategies would you use to increase the student's ability to summarize or re-tell the information that was read?

If a student is having difficulty retell a story, I would plan to have stronger readers model what they are thinking and questioning as they are reading. The student can also write simple words of what he remembers in the story, act out or draw his favorite part. For summarizing, I think the example in the powerpoint would be very effective. Oftentimes I have one or two students that can tell every detail and others that can only tell a few, as well as skipping around the whole time. I think if we sat in the circle, the students not only have an opportunity to name a detail but they do have that visual. In addition, I would probably draw a timeline on the board so we can make sure we stay on track and not skip around. I have student imparticular without ASD, but he has EXTREME difficulty with comprehension. I think these strategies would be very helpful as I feel like I have ran out of every idea I can think of. It will be nice to try some new things.

Britton said...

I like Melanie's graphic organizer of the four-square chart. I think the smaller squares would be less intimidating than a blank piece of paper for a summary to be written on,and the adaptation for drawing instead of words for some.

Britton said...

I would use a graphic organizer, a partial outline of the material or a summary with key words omitted for students to fill in. After reading the outline or summary upon completion, I would get the student to draw an illustration, make a collage illustration, or even a powerpoint.

Joan Fazzino said...

I like Britton's ideas of having an outline or summary with key words omitted for the students to fill in. That makes it less overwhelming for students who have difficulty writing or doing a whole summary on their own. I also think the "hands on activities" such as collages,drawings or creating power points is a good way for students to learn and retain knowledge.

Anonymous said...

My students make Index Card Kites to identify and summarize specifics on a topic we are studying. These kites have an index card stating whatever we are studying with a long piece of adding machine paper hanging under it. Students attach subsequent index cards along the "tail" of the kite with specific details pertaining to the subject matter. I then have the students go to the kite, read their classmates' index card details, and then tell me something they didn't know before. We play this game frequently during the course of study. We also make acrostic poetry, flip books, and circular maps (paper plates) to recall subject matter. All of these strategies combined with allowing the students to illustrate with drawings, models, and mini museums would help increase my ASD students' ability to summarize or re-tell the information that was read.

I like Melanie's "four square chart" which allows for Reciprocal Teaching and helps the ASD student with their difficulty in language comprehension.

Anonymous said...

I am really excited about trying the Index Card Kites idea in my inclusion classes this year. In addition to the visual display, I think I may make a study guide that looks just like it for students to fill in. This way they have notes to study from. To differentiate, some students could receive study guides with information filled in and others would have to add more details. I am curious to see how this would work in Language Arts. Maybe the index cards could contain the who, what, where and why information.

A Eller said...

I let the students role play or re-enact events from the story. I put them in three groups (one group for the beginning, one for the middle, and one for the end). Students are working together, retelling the story, and also developing sequencing skills.

A Eller said...

Joan, I like how you use puppets and flannel boards to help students retell stories. Not only is that age-appropriate for primary students, but it helps motivate them to learn by getting to use the puppets and pictures and manipulate them to deepen their understanding.

Cathy Parker said...

In my class the students are unable to read yet. They are young and are learning to read names of their classmates. I would first use questions and answers to check for comprehension. Response could be verbal or pointing. Then they would use a picture to re-tell the story and then several pictures to re-tell the story or summarize. My students love photos and this brings their interest to the lesson or story.

Anonymous said...

I agree with Joan that the use of pictures and puppets are very useful tool in my classroom. I still have difficulty with my ASD students responding when requested but I listen as they use the puppets with other students about the stories. Also, the non-verbal students can act out the story with puppets or cut-outs.

Cathy Parker said...

I agree with Joan that the use of pictures and puppets are very useful tool in my classroom. I still have difficulty with my ASD students responding when requested but I listen as they use the puppets with other students about the stories. Also, the non-verbal students can act out the story with puppets or cut-outs.

Brewington said...

I really like the four square chart that Melanie described. This could be modified in so many ways to accomodate lots of students. I also agree with the role playing, puppets, etc.

If a student with ASD had trouble with comprehension, I would try letting them draw their retelling of the story. I know of a student that this worked very well with. Once she read the book she would draw her retell and tell you about the story through her drawing.

Gardin said...

I would definitely try to give the student some type of guided notes. As we were reading the story the student could fill in key phrases, highlight important words, or draw important scenes. All of this would depend on the student's level on readiness. Many student's minds wander (mine included!) and they have trouble with reading comprehension because they haven't focused the whole time. Guided notes can help with that. Also, I would stop several times throughout the story and ask students to retell it. Hearing it over and over could help with comprehension.

Melanie's Four Squares can be used as guided notes. I really like that idea and will adapt it for my class this year!!

Jordanadan said...

I like Joan have students with limited verbal abilities and using props, puppets and pictures really help students to identify key components of stories and they also use those picture symbols to answer questions related to texts.

Jordanadan said...

I also incorporate pictures and props to make venn diagrams (sometimes 3 dimensional) to help my students make comparisons and contrasts within a story. It really helps them to see major differences especially in comparing two pieces of literature.

Kelly Hollingsworth said...

Joan, I really like your idea of using props and words to retell the story. When students are given visual cues and props, they are able to be much more successful. Also, I like hearing strategies used by Melanie Endres and Britton because my mind is always geared towards younger children, and I think that you guys have some great ideas to reach older and higher functioning students.

Kelly Hollingsworth said...

Last year in my classroom of students who were middle school age, we read a story about the story of Thanksgiving. We were hosting a family dinner and presentation in our classroom, and I wanted my students to be able to fully comprehend the story/meaning so that we could share it when the parents came to visit. I knew that we first had to target comprehension before we could even begin to practice sharing it. In order to help my students, I used visual aids including key words, pictures, and story boards. I also used costumes and allowed them to dress up as characters from our story. When it was time for our presentation, the students were able to share the story almost perfectly. They made me really proud!

Melanie Tanczos said...

I like the idea of using Card Kites to get the students engaged in reading comprehension. I also think I will use the flip books as well as Melanie's four squares idea. These will be less difficult when students have a purpose or a starting point.

Chandra Wilkins said...

My student with ASD has extreme difficulty comprehending what she fluenetly reads. I started scanning her stories into Kurzweil. After we would read the story together she was able to go to the computer to listen to the story repeatedly. This would enhance her comprehension and allow her to discuss the story in detail with me.

Chandra Wilkins said...

I agree with Britton that the use of a graphic orgainzer, guided notes, would prove helpful. Eller's idea of re-enacting the events in the story is a good idea.

Ram said...

I agree with the joan ‘s using props, puppets and pictures really help students to identify the key components of stories and Melanie’s Four squares which can use as guided notes for increase the student’s ability to summarize or re-tell the information that read.

Ram said...

I am having the student able to read the material fluently but had difficulty in reading comprehension. We use the guided notes and some pictures related to the reading material filed in and other would have to more details. I would like to try with graphic organizer and with a partial outline material or a summary to summarize or re-tell information that was read.

Stephanie Davis said...

In the past I have used "Movie Magic" for comprehension. The students take the information they have read/heard and re-write a script that could be used for a movie.

I also like tape recorders. I have had several of my students re-tell the story into a tape player. They are surprised at the details they picked up and just as surprised by the ones they left out.

Stephanie Davis said...

I think I am coming up as Anonymous too. Sorry. Have no clue!

Stephanie Davis said...

I also use the outline such as Britton's where I leave out words or phrases for my higher functioning children to fill in the blanks. Once they check their own papers, they move on to help the lower functioning students.

Stephanie Davis said...

Like Joan, our autistic teacher loves her flannel board. I thought they had gone by the wayside but she lives by it. "Nathan" uses it for every aspect of his day from reading comprehension to personal hygiene.

Becker said...

If a student with ASD is having difficulty with reading comprehension even though the student is able to read the material fluently, the strategies that I would use to increase the student's ability to summarize or re-tell the information that was read would that I would chose material that the student enjoy or have an interest in. I would reread the story to them several times, and then I would have them reread the story several times. I my even begin with material that was a movie and then have them read the actual book. I would have them compare and contrast the text to the movie.
Also as I read or they read the material, I would ask many questions concerning compression. Most importantly I would have them draw a picture or cartoon concerning the written material. After the reading is completed, I would ask comprehension questions concerning the drawing.

Becker said...

I like Melanie's graphic organizer of the four-square chart. . Many ASD students have writer block when it comes to a blank piece of paper. I may start some of the sentences in each block so that student only has to worry about the compression of the story and mechanics. This organizer may start off as a whole group project then to a small group and the finally to an individual exercise.

SusanHGilstrap said...

I absolutely LOVE teacherlmo's idea about the index card kites. I am certainly going to try this idea out this year. Thanks for sharing!!

SusanHGilstrap said...

Reading comprehension problems are the hardest ones to "fix," in my opinion. By adding in a problem of communicating to the teacher what the story/passage was about makes a teacher's job even more difficult.

I think it is very important to pick reading materials that are of interest to the child, and they certainly must be on his/her grade level. When asking the child to retell events in the story, I would use various questioning, and refer to the pictures in the story as much as possible. I would allow the student to use the computer to respond (to encourage more of a dialogue between us), but I would also accept words and phrases from the child. If the child said a word or a short phrase (that has merit in what I was looking for), I would work with the child to try to get him to elaborate on what he said. This may be by putting his one word (or short phrase) in the form of a question, and letting him answer me.

Melissa Melton said...

I think the key is finding a way to help students process all the language that makes up stories. The explanations need to be concrete, which might be accomplished by trying to break the information down into factual components while taking some of the mystery out of the emotional and implied undercurrents that might not be readily understood by students with ASD. Providing a story map to help the student understand a pretictible way of breaking down a story could also be beneficial. Pre-teaching the parts of a story including beginning, middle, end, characters, themes, perspective, etc. helps to break down the sometimes daunting onslaught of words that face students who struggle to make sense of language. Once the student becomes familiar with the chosen format, they can become more purpsoeful readers because they have a template in mind that guides how they process the layers of information that make up a story.

Melissa Melton said...

I like that Kelly Hollingsworth was able to pair an actual opportunity for her students to experience first hand that which they had read about. What a great way to make a story meaningful and promote generalization of the concepts that will surely be reinforced throughout the years as the students again and again participate in this important tradition with a new sense of understanding.

Doris said...

Students that I work with have no reading skills... I would have students first watch a performance (with skills I would like to teach, such as color concepts, spacial concepts)from a favorite tv show (such as sponge bob or bob the builder). Then allow them to reinact. Also having the other students all learn the same parts for retelling. Then each student would have a turn rehearsing as in a play so that they could play each others part. The repetion would help each student.

Doris said...

I really like what Eller said about putting student in three groups (beginning, middle and end).
That would help for any group of language student and is a very good idea. Thanks!